An-Ice question

Started by dextrous63, January 11, 2025, 05:08:17 PM

« previous - next »

dextrous63

When carts, tractors, cars etc drive one after the other over grass, they leave a track consisting of two worn parallel lines, with untouched grass between and beyond this lines/ruts.

The question I have is...why do busy-ish roads have no ice on them rather than parallel lines?  

Alex


Scrumpy

🔔 📞 📞
  ' Um ! umm !! Sorry Alex.. I don't know.. Best ask the audience '
Don't ask me.. I know nuffink..

klondike

Quote from: dextrous63 on January 11, 2025, 05:08:17 PMThe question I have is...why do busy-ish roads have no ice on them rather than parallel lines? 
Because the council grit them?

Artificial Intelligence is no match for natural stupidity

dextrous63

Quote from: klondike on January 11, 2025, 06:12:28 PMBecause the council grit them?
Highly unlikely.  But even if they did, the grit wouldn't melt the entire surface, surely,

Alex

Quote from: Scrumpy on January 11, 2025, 06:10:54 PM🔔 📞 📞
  ' Um ! umm !! Sorry Alex.. I don't know.. Best ask the audience '

Audience said different sized vehicles ? :smiley:

klondike

Quote from: dextrous63 on January 11, 2025, 06:23:26 PMHighly unlikely.  But even if they did, the grit wouldn't melt the entire surface, surely,
The grit is partly salt crystals. The salt dissolves and raises the freezing point of a small amount of water and that spreads by itself and on car tyres and melts even more frost. Before too long the entire surface gets covered with salty water which is above the freezing point of salty water.

Have you never scattered salt on a frozen path? It isn't necessary to carefully cover the entire path with salt. It melts the frost and spreads itself.

Artificial Intelligence is no match for natural stupidity

dextrous63

Quote from: Alex on January 11, 2025, 06:33:22 PMAudience said different sized vehicles ? :smiley:
Possible, and that would explain wider ruts in the snow.  Still can't see how that'd clear the entire surface though.🤷🏻�♂️
Quote from: klondike on January 11, 2025, 07:42:14 PMThe grit is partly salt crystals. The salt dissolves and raises the freezing point of a small amount of water and that spreads by itself and on car tyres and melts even more frost. Before too long the entire surface gets covered with salty water which is above the freezing point of salty water.

Have you never scattered salt on a frozen path? It isn't necessary to carefully cover the entire path with salt. It melts the frost and spreads itself.
That makes more sense, thanks.  In the absence of any other reason, other than huge amounts of underfloor heating going on🤣🤣🤣, I'll settle for that.  Just seems amazing how such a relatively tiny amount of salt can create sufficient quantities of saline of an appropriate strength.

Mups

Quote from: dextrous63 on January 11, 2025, 05:08:17 PMWhen carts, tractors, cars etc drive one after the other over grass, they leave a track consisting of two worn parallel lines, with untouched grass between and beyond this lines/ruts.

The question I have is...why do busy-ish roads have no ice on them rather than parallel lines? 

Because there are many more cars on the roads than tractors on grass.  And thousands of cars don't all follow exactly in the previous ones tyre marks, so the ice melts the width of the road in the end.

Also, as Klondike said,  don't forget the gritters.  They don't do much gritting on grass, so the frost stays put.  :smiley:

klondike

TBH it isn't something that I've given much thought to but there isn't a huge amount of water in a layer of frost or snow come to that as a lot of it is mostly air. Add to that the pressure under car tyres is going to produce a bit of heat too.

Artificial Intelligence is no match for natural stupidity

dextrous63

There are a couple of threads about the recent cold weather, but I'll put my comment here if that's ok.

Have any of you spotted the alarming number of drivers who don't seem to understand that cold, icy roads require more care and attention than usual,

Ashy

I'd venture to suggest that the vehicle, particularly the engine, warms the space between the wheels. The wheels themselves would only crush the snow into that thick sort of cake icing but to melt it requires warmth. 

klondike

With enough traffic they'll warm the air a little but I think they pass over too quickly to melt ice. The reason main roads are clear of frost is gritting which lowers the freezing point of water. Look at side roads - they stay frosty apart from maybe wheel tracks until there is a thaw.

Artificial Intelligence is no match for natural stupidity

JBR

Fortunately, most of the snow and ice around here has melted (though I don't know about Scotland).

Next, the floods come!
Numquam credere Gallicum